The Ultimate When to Plant Guide

February 2nd, 2010 by David LaFerney Leave a reply »

My Garden in April

Pay attention.  This may be the most valuable tidbit of gardening wisdom anyone ever hands you. Of course it also might not be.

When to plant – every seed packet you pick up has a little map on the back with 4 or 5 colored zones and planting dates for each zone.  Or they have cryptic advice like “whenever soil can be worked”, “after soil has thoroughly warmed”, or “after all danger of frost.”    Forget all that.  Plant when the soil is the right temperature.  Period.   Depending upon how sheltered your garden is, or if it has shade in the morning or afternoon – or if it is in a greenhouse or cold frame – those dates are just about meaningless.  But, the soil temperature will almost never lead you astray because the ground temperature changes slowly – it is slow to warm up in the spring, and slow to cool off in the fall.  Not wildly swinging with every warm or cold front.

Seed Germination time in days at different temperatures

degrees F 32 41 50 59 68 77 86 95 104
parsnips 172 57 27 20 14 15 32
onion 136 50 13 7 5 4 4 13
spinach 62.6 23 12 7 6 5 6
lettuce 49 15 7 4 3 2 3
cabbage 51 17 10 7 6 6 9
carrots 50 17 10 7 6 6 9
celery 41 16 12 7
peas 36 14 9 8 6 6
radishes 29 11 6 4 4 4 3
asparagus 52 24 14 10 11 19 28
tomatoes 43 14 8 6 6 9
parsley 29 17 14 13 12
sweet corn 21.6 12 7 4 4 3
cauliflower 19 9 6 5 5
beets 14 9 6 5 6
turnips 5 3 2 1 1 1 3
lima beans 30 17 6 7
okra 27 17 12 7 6 7
peppers 25 13 8 8 9
snap beans 16 11 8 6 6
cucumbers, summer and winter squash
13 6 4 3 5
eggplant 13 8 5
watermelon 12 5 4 3
muskmellon 8 4 3

As a general rule seeds that can germinate at a lower temperature are also more resistant to rot.

If you study this table you will begin to understand why those melons never came up – too cool/wet and they rot, too warm – they just never germinate.  You will also understand what “as soon as soil can be worked” means – a lot of things can be planted in 41 degree soil (or colder) and will just take a long time to come up unless the soil warms first like in the spring time – in which case they spring up quicker.  You can also understand this – if it will germinate in very cold soil then the plant will probably tolerate some cold spring (or even winter) weather.  So – onions, lettuce, spinach, and those which will germinate at 32 degrees can be planted any time after the weather cools down in the fall and they will basically come up when the time is right and be fine – especially if they are sheltered in a cold frame.

If you are starting seeds indoors you can see why it’s so hard to get tomatoes to come up in that sunny (but cold at night) window – those little plugs of soil do cool off quickly unlike the soil in your garden.  Those tomatoes, peppers and other warm season tropical plants will get off to a galloping start if you can consistently keep them a bit warmer – like with home made bottom heat made from rope lights.

On the other end of the chart – when it is too hot for the seeds to germinate, most plants start to stress or die from heat, especially if they aren’t kept watered.  So those cool season crops need to be planted when it is cold so that they can make a crop before it gets too hot.  Warm season crops will do great if you plant them when the soil is just barely (or almost) warm enough, and then cover them with a fabric or plastic row cover or cold frame.  Cucumbers really will come up in 3 days if you do this.

BTW, one of those digital kitchen thermometers works great for checking soil temp.   If you don’t already have a cold frame then cut the bottom off of a 2 liter coke bottle and leave it in the garden pushed into the ground like you were covering a plant with it – check the temp under that in a day or two, and you will want to get a cold frame.  Of course you can also cover your seeds with the bottom of a 2 liter bottle (or plastic milk jug) until they come up.

If you take this one thing seriously and plant your garden as early as possible, but when the soil is warm enough you’re gardening prowess will leap forward by the equivalent of 20 years of experience.  I sure wish someone had handed this to me 20 years ago!

Need planting information for something that isn’t on the chart?  Search using this customized Google search engine. Try searching for – zucchini soil temperature – for example.

Gardening Search Engine – all results are from top US Agricultural Universities.

Advertisement

14 comments

  1. Daisy says:

    This was a great article. I remember a master gardener friend of mine talking about soil temperature, but this article really cemented the concept in my mind. I will do more research and I will go by soil temp as my main planting guide this season.
    Thanks

  2. Karen Stonebridge says:

    Great advice! I will print. Also, the trick with having spinach, or other cold tolerant plants for the fall/winter (at least here in Maine’s zone 5) is trying to get them to germinate at the beginning of August when the soil temp is at about its highest. This year I think I will try keeping them in the basement until they germinate and then transplant to the garden. Results to follow – in August.

  3. margaret cunningham says:

    brilliant advice …many thanks…am trying to do things in a more structured fashion this year and hoping for a longer season rather than haphazardly throwing things in the ground and keeping the paws crossed! am keeping a journal too. will be sort of doing a mobile small hoop house with leftover plastic, strong cable and a wood base… if i get the time! will let you know how it goes! thanks again, mags

  4. Matt says:

    Thanks again David, good stuff as usual. Hope my health gets better soon enough so that I can get back at it.

  5. David says:

    I’m totally impressed by everything you do! Keep up the excellent site.

  6. Den says:

    Hi David
    Came to check out your blog after your helpful commentsin response to mine on the recent Fast Grow the Weeds post. What a great blog! The detail here is phenomenal. It’s so great to find such dedicated folk as you, willing to share all this wisdom – with pictures!! Thank you! I have checked out the cold frame & greenhouse designs and am raring to give them a go. Hubby is sceptical – he reckons the wind here (it does get crazily blowy!) will flatten the greenhouse. What’s your experience with wind?
    This post on seed germination is excellent & very timely – such a relief to have what I have always suspected confirmed – that the advice on seed packets is fallible! I will be following your posts with great interest from now on. Great to have met you in this bloggy world…
    Den from A Full Monte Life

    • David LaFerney says:

      Welcome Den, I’m glad you like it. Will the wind blow down my greenhouse? If it blows hard enough it will. No telling what point will be hard enough. So far 40 MPH during a storm hasn’t done any damage. 3 inches of wet snow however graphically indicated that It needs a bit more structural integrity. I’m working on that.

      Thanks for your encouraging comment.

  7. Mal says:

    Hi David,

    I’ve been attempting to analyse this data too. What is beginning to bother me is that EVERYONE relies on the one set of statistics which now go back a long way. (The give away is that the list of plants is always the same asparagus and muskmelon included. Also you can tell the temperatuers were originally in Cenigrade as they are 0,5,10,15 etc) There were some glaring holes in the data too which were put down to crop failure. Has no one replicated these findings? (I’m going to use your search box to see). The main thing is that sorting the data into order by temperature ensures that you at least know the correct ORDER to sow things in, even if you don’t have a soil thermometer! Which reminds me to ask: Which temperature was used in the original studt? Air, Surface or Soil (1cm) Soil (5cm) or the one meteoroligists tend to use which is 30cm depth? Probably they were all the same for the controlled conditions of the original study, but where does that leave us practiotioners who can’t rely on such controlled conditions. What do you think?

    • You are correct – this data is pretty old. But it works. There are indeed holes in it that you will have to fill with research and judgment. Nonetheless I stand by my position that using this will improve a beginners success and consistency by the equivalent of many years of learning by experience.

      I use a $20 digital oven thermometer stuck into the top 3 inches (more or less) of soil. It may not be the perfect thing, but it works.

      Let me know if you find better/newer/more complete data, or something that you think works better. Thanks.

      • Mal says:

        David, I’m certainly not having a go at you or expecting you (or I) to plug the gaps of the horticultural research literature. I’m really impressed at how you’ve managed to make the data intelligible in one post! I took two and I still feel I’ve just baffled readers. Surely in the years since the study was done somebody in one of the agricultural colleges or universities has published results. Maybe they are secret for commercial growers(?)
        Wouldn’t it have been great if someone had tried smaller increments at the lower temperatues as it’s always a close call as to when to start sowing, and I would guess many start too cold out of impatience (or because they are reading blogs from people living further south – Northern Hemisphere only). 5 degrees C is a big jump at the cool end of the year. I look forward to your further posts as you’ve always got a refreshing angle on vegetable growing. Mal

        • David LaFerney says:

          I hope I didn’t sound put off – not at all. I agree with you all around. It seems that someone should produce and publish more recent data on this, along with practical application advice.

          I like your blog BTW. I believe I referenced it (if I remember correctly) in my recent bit on forced rhubarb.

  8. Kirsten says:

    Such a useful blog you write! – great information and I appreciate your use of photos to illustrate your points. I’m definitely clicking the RSS button :-)

    • Mark400 says:

      Whenever I determined to start plant seeds the main thing that came to my mind is the time of planting the seeds.I am really confuse what to do!When I read your article it gave me extra courage about planting seeds.The main thing that you told in your article that the temperature of soil,is really interesting.I don’t even think about it.Thank you for your article.
      garden cloches

Leave a Reply

SEO Powered by Platinum SEO from Techblissonline